Skip to main content

Book Review: A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness.


Book Review: A Discovery of Witches, Book I of All Souls Trilogy by Deborah Harkness.



Quote: What a complicated, delicate business it was going to be to love him. We were the stuff of fairy tales-- vampires, witches, knights in shining armour. But there was a troubling reality to face. I had been threatened, and creatures watched me in the Bodleian in hopes I'd recall a book that everyone wanted but no one understood. Mathew's laboratory had been targeted. And our relationship was destabilizing the fragile détente that had long existed among daemons, humans, vampires, and witches.


I saw the trailer of the series and I had to get the books before I watched it. Before people judge me, I loved Twilight Series when I was young, Vampires have since then made a space in my mind. But for a long time, I was craving a big book with fictive facts, logic, and research in its story. This book is an answer to my discovery.

A Romeo-Juliet love story set in Oxford University. Diana Bishop is a historian with acclaim and a witch in denial, she is terrible at spells, haunted by the murder of her parents and she avoids her witching community, though the Bodleian library is stacked with creatures. With autumn equinox nearing she finds the bewitched Ashmole 782, missing for 150 years. After glancing through it she returns it!

Mathew Clairmont a fellow professor at Oxford and member of Royal Society and a vampire as old as time, finds her. After initial anger, chasing and hissing, few yoga dates and sexual frustration later, they fall in love. A love against the congregation that forbids inter-species love.

The best thing about the book is its detailed research, and the underlying themes of extinction, ignorance, and fear. People are after Diana because she is the twisted key, a broken chosen one who chose to be blind to her powers. Mathew is equally flawed, he will kill to protect Diana and has no remorse at times. He is no saviour, he protects only what he wants to and loves. He will burn the whole world down if it means protecting his family. They both are not perfect together, they are ticking time bomb even their 'madly in love' is scary to themselves, as they escalated to love with weeks of knowing each other.

I loved the communication this couple has as they talk with each other and discuss plans and still end up taking stupid steps, neither do they trust each other's decision making completely. Despite all the threat and danger from evil witches and vampires, they don't stop admiring books and history around them. They literally Geek about the books Mathew has collected over the centuries.

The range of women characters is so refreshing! A lesbian couple for aunts, ghost grandmother, evil witches, matriarchal vampire, disoriented assassin vampire, scatterbrained daemons! Each woman giving her opinion or piece of power to Diana.

Mathew and Marcus are finding information about all the lineages and explain that the three magical creatures are dying through years of research he has accumulated gives us the overwhelming sense of time's cruelty. Even 3000 years is not enough to solve the mystery of life and death.

At times Diana is frustrating, he is so rigid and stubborn. She can read through texts after text, has a Ph.D. in the history of science and is studying Alchemy, yet she refuses to learn her spells properly and gives up easily. Even Mathew goes frustrated with her, but what's a damsel that's not distressed?

I loved all the information about alchemy that was presented in the book, through poetry and literature of old. Book also explains every tropey legend with a logic and science behind it. The reference to Shakespeare, the fictional confirmation of public's curiosity if Marlowe was gay, the tiny passing remarks on Medici family and the question what did Lazarus became after he was revived? Most probably the first vampire!


And there is time travel, a very logical one on top of that!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Book Review: When The River Sleeps by Easterine Kire.

Book Review: When The River Sleeps by Easterine Kire. Quote: Perhaps the answer lay not in striving but in being. In simply accepting that the loneliness would never be eliminated fully, but that one could deal with it by learning to treat it like a companion and no longer an adversary. Ville a hunter wakes up from a dream, ventures out to search for the heart-stone; that holds the power of the river that's asleep. And this stone is guarded by wailing-angry-widow-spirits. Many attempts have been made at magical realism in Indian English writing, and I didn't like them. My personal opinion is that magical realism needs a deep connection with nature, maybe never explicitly explored in the text, but the traces of that connection always shows in the words written. And I have always argued that North East India is the most fertile ground to plant the seeds of magical realism in. Easterine Kire, pens our deep connection with nature for the national readership to gawk...

Webcomic Review: One Day by Pan

Webcomic Review: One Day by Pan (link at bottom) Quote: You love the book The Dreamcatcher, right? Hum...right. That novel is really awesome! I've come to your store for three days. Finally, I finished it. What? You finished all of it? One Day is a short webcomic that's sweet, fluffy and warm like pancakes which leave you happy after you devour it. In a rainy city, Bella a bookworm college student meets a backpacker in the bookshop she works at. They bond over an out of print book that Bella hides behind shelves so that she can finish it before someone buys it. They walk around the city, have coffee in Bella's favourite café and talk about their looming future as working adult. Bella doesn't want to work in a corporate job but her family is strict, and her new friend has a little secret of his own. There are two side stories, of a tomboy teen named Luciana who has a crush on her basketball teammate, and how her friends try to d...

Unrequited? Nah, I am Bhaizoned!

[Another Bloagathon! This is for Women's Web  Finding Mr. Right Stories competition in tie up with the Woo App ] Love has been a constant in this blogger’s life, I have always been in love with the idea of love. Fueled by Mills and Boons initially, I always wanted a Tall, Dark, Handsome lover, well I was fifteen when I read my first Mills and Boon, the shift to Tall, Fair, Handsome Vampire happened quickly at sixteen, and I wanted a blood sucking creature for my husband. While Elizabeth Bennet said yes to Darcy, I sighed and imagined myself in her gowns and laces! Oh, how much I love those silly novels by lady novelist and how much I waste my monthly allowance on them!  The Twilight hangover had made a racist out of me and I would hanker after any cute fair guy with decent height! It was always the lips of the guys that caught my eyes first. By the time, I reached enlightened eighteen my eyes searched for Jang Keun Suk alike, Suk is the perfect blend of husk...